608 F. Supp. 2d 351, 2009 WL 485563, 2009 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 19891
CV-04-2799 (NG)(VVP), CV-04-5449 (NG)(VVP), CV-04-5564 (NG)(VVP), CV-05-365 (NG)(VVP), CV-05-388 (NG)(VVP), CV-05-3183 (NG)(VVP), CV-05-3738 (NG)(VVP), CV-06-1623 (NG)(VVP), CV-06-3869 (NG)(VVP)